Gadianton / Gaddianton Variant: Difference between revisions
(Created page with "'''Gadianton / Gaddianton Variant''' - Helaman 2:4 O: Gaddianton/Gadianton PA: Gadianton 1830 – 1981 RLDS 1908 Helaman 2:11 O: Gaddianton P: Gadiantom >% Gadianton 183...") |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
'''Gadianton / Gaddianton Variant''' | '''Gadianton / Gaddianton Variant''' | ||
Helaman 2:4 | |||
O: Gaddianton/Gadianton | O: Gaddianton/Gadianton | ||
| Line 7: | Line 7: | ||
PA: Gadianton 1830 – 1981 RLDS 1908 | PA: Gadianton 1830 – 1981 RLDS 1908 | ||
Helaman 2:11 | |||
O: Gaddianton | O: Gaddianton | ||
| Line 13: | Line 13: | ||
P: Gadiantom >% Gadianton 1830 – 1981 RLDS 1908 | P: Gadiantom >% Gadianton 1830 – 1981 RLDS 1908 | ||
Helaman 2:12 | |||
O: Gaddianton | O: Gaddianton | ||
| Line 19: | Line 19: | ||
PA: Gadianton 1830 – 1981 RLDS 1908 | PA: Gadianton 1830 – 1981 RLDS 1908 | ||
4 Nephi 1:42 | |||
P: Gaddiaton A: Gaddianton 1830 – 1841 1840: Gadianton 1840 1852 – 1981 RLDS 1908 | P: Gaddiaton A: Gaddianton 1830 – 1841 1840: Gadianton 1840 1852 – 1981 RLDS 1908 | ||
4 Nephi 1:46 | |||
P, A: Gaddianton 1830 – 1841 | P, A: Gaddianton 1830 – 1841 | ||
| Line 29: | Line 29: | ||
1840: Gadianton 1840 1852 – 1981 RLDS 1908 | 1840: Gadianton 1840 1852 – 1981 RLDS 1908 | ||
Mormon 1:18 | |||
PA: Gaddianton 1830 – 1841 | PA: Gaddianton 1830 – 1841 | ||
| Line 35: | Line 35: | ||
?1852: Gadianton 1852 – 1981 RLDS 1908 | ?1852: Gadianton 1852 – 1981 RLDS 1908 | ||
Mormon 2:27, 28 | |||
PA: Gaddianton 1830 – 1841 | PA: Gaddianton 1830 – 1841 | ||
| Line 41: | Line 41: | ||
1840: Gadianton 1840 1852 – 1981 RLDS 1908 | 1840: Gadianton 1840 1852 – 1981 RLDS 1908 | ||
Discussion: For the first occurrence, spacing between extant fragments of O supports the longer spelling, Gaddianton. The line below it lines up to 14 characters with the missing name and its following space. If it had not been Gaddianton, or Cowdery had crossed out one of the d's, why would he forget the spelling a few verses later? In | |||
the Book of Mormon, we find examples of both single and double-d spellings with gad or gid, as in Gadiandi and Giddianhi. | the Book of Mormon, we find examples of both single and double-d spellings with gad or gid, as in Gadiandi and Giddianhi. | ||
Revision as of 08:47, 18 February 2011
Gadianton / Gaddianton Variant
Helaman 2:4
O: Gaddianton/Gadianton
PA: Gadianton 1830 – 1981 RLDS 1908
Helaman 2:11
O: Gaddianton
P: Gadiantom >% Gadianton 1830 – 1981 RLDS 1908
Helaman 2:12
O: Gaddianton
PA: Gadianton 1830 – 1981 RLDS 1908
4 Nephi 1:42
P: Gaddiaton A: Gaddianton 1830 – 1841 1840: Gadianton 1840 1852 – 1981 RLDS 1908
4 Nephi 1:46
P, A: Gaddianton 1830 – 1841
1840: Gadianton 1840 1852 – 1981 RLDS 1908
Mormon 1:18
PA: Gaddianton 1830 – 1841
?1852: Gadianton 1852 – 1981 RLDS 1908
Mormon 2:27, 28
PA: Gaddianton 1830 – 1841
1840: Gadianton 1840 1852 – 1981 RLDS 1908
Discussion: For the first occurrence, spacing between extant fragments of O supports the longer spelling, Gaddianton. The line below it lines up to 14 characters with the missing name and its following space. If it had not been Gaddianton, or Cowdery had crossed out one of the d's, why would he forget the spelling a few verses later? In the Book of Mormon, we find examples of both single and double-d spellings with gad or gid, as in Gadiandi and Giddianhi.
Summary: Skousen accepts Gaddianton, in accordance with the two extant readings in O, and the spacing in O for the first occurrence
Source: ATV 5:2894-96, 3223-24
Other occurrences not discussed in ATV: Helaman 2:13; 3:23; 6:18 (3x), 24, 26 (2x), 29, 37; 7:4, 25; 8:1, 28; 11:10, 26 (2x); 3 Nephi 1:27, 29; 2:11, 12, 18; 3:9, 15
