Abinadi Variants: Difference between revisions
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 2: | Line 2: | ||
- Mosiah 26:15 | - Mosiah 26:15 | ||
P: Aminadi > NULL | |||
Discussion: Scribe 2 wrote Aminadi but immediately caught his error and changed it to Abinadi in | Discussion: Scribe 2 wrote Aminadi but immediately caught his error and changed it to Abinadi in P. It was the first time that Scribe 2 had to write Abinadi, so a mistake is not surprising. | ||
Acceptability: Scribal error; Abinadi correct | Acceptability: Scribal error; Abinadi correct | ||
Source: ATV 3:1485 | Source: ATV 3:1485 | ||
| Line 11: | Line 11: | ||
1: Abinedi | 1: Abinedi | ||
Discussion: Scribe 2 wrote the name as Abinedi in | Discussion: Scribe 2 wrote the name as Abinedi in P. It may have read the same in O, and "could have occurred if Joseph Smith pronounced the word with | ||
stress on the second syllable so that the third vowel would have been the unstressed schwa vowel" (ATV 3:1485). | stress on the second syllable so that the third vowel would have been the unstressed schwa vowel" (ATV 3:1485). | ||
Acceptability: Scribal error; Abinadi correct | Acceptability: Scribal error; Abinadi correct | ||
Revision as of 08:42, 18 February 2011
Abinadi-Variant
- Mosiah 26:15 P: Aminadi > NULL
Discussion: Scribe 2 wrote Aminadi but immediately caught his error and changed it to Abinadi in P. It was the first time that Scribe 2 had to write Abinadi, so a mistake is not surprising. Acceptability: Scribal error; Abinadi correct Source: ATV 3:1485 - Alma 5:11
1: Abinedi
Discussion: Scribe 2 wrote the name as Abinedi in P. It may have read the same in O, and "could have occurred if Joseph Smith pronounced the word with stress on the second syllable so that the third vowel would have been the unstressed schwa vowel" (ATV 3:1485). Acceptability: Scribal error; Abinadi correct Source: ATV 3:1485
General Summary: These two variants are scribal errors, and Abinadi is correct The 37 other occurrences all read Abinadi in P: Mosiah 11:20, 26, 27 (2x), 28, 29; 12:1 (2x), 8, 17, 25, 33, 37; 13:5, 25; 15:1; 16:1; 17:1, 2 (3x), 4, 5, 7, 9, 20; 18:1; 20:21; 21:30 (2x); 24:5, 9; Alma 25:9, 11; Mormon 1:19 (37 times total)
